More details on the challenge to Scars

Through Kids Right to Read/ABFFE, which contacted the Boone County Public Library in Kentucky about the challenge to Scars, we’ve been told that:

“…after they got the patron complaint, they put together a panel of librarians (YA librarian, children’s adult – several others; a good range), who convened a meeting to discuss the validity of the challenge. They have already made the decision but have yet to tell the complainer about it…and don’t want it getting out yet,…[so] they didn’t divulge the outcome.” We were told “that no book has ever been pulled from that library.” We’re also told that we’ll know the outcome in a day or so.

We also found out that “the patron complained because of the content,” believing “that the book could contain triggers for self-harming teens or those who used to harm themselves but no longer do.” Perhaps there is the unfounded fear that “This could make kids cut themselves!” (a ridiculous assertion) or perhaps it’s a relatively (if misguided) legitimate concern from a parent or teen.”

7 Responses to “More details on the challenge to Scars”

  1. Tweets that mention Cheryl Rainfield: » More details on the challenge to Scars -- Says:

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Anne Mazer and Cheryl Rainfield, Catherine Ryan Hyde. Catherine Ryan Hyde said: RT @CherylRainfield: More details on the challenge to Scars Pls RT! […]

  2. Kathy Quimby Says:

    Sounds to me like this patron, who seems to have acted out of a concern that at least has to do with thinking of other people, doesn’t understand that while not every book is for every reader, it’s not up to patrons to decide what books are available to other readers.

  3. Cheryl Rainfield Says:

    I agree, Kathy–it’s up to each of us to decide what we will read or not read. Not for others to decide for us!

  4. June Says:

    I think this patron meant well, but he or she doesn’t have the clinical knowledge base to understand that a person without underlying issues is not going to influenced in that manner.
    A book can’t be pulled with the fear that a few might. The psychodynamics involved are more complex than that.

  5. Cheryl Rainfield Says:

    I agree. And each person deals with self-harm their own way–though many of us find it helps to know that we’re not alone.

  6. Heidi Ayarbe Says:

    Cheryl RAinfield is a fearless author, and I believe these librarians will be fearless as well. Not every book is for every reader, no doubt. But that’s not something anybody else should decide for me or my child.
    Banning books, censorship, and pulling books off shelves is a scary thing. I’m pulling for SCARS … backing this library that, I believe, will come forward to do the right thing.

  7. Cheryl Rainfield Says:

    Thank you, Heidi. I agree–librarians are amazing, and often fearless. And you’re right, not every book is for every person, but we should each have the choice. I think censorship and banning books is scary, too. Thank you so much for your support!

Leave a Comment

Love my books? Here's how to help!

Reasons Not To Hurt Yourself

Reasons Not To Kill Yourself. If You're Thinking of Suicide...

Tips On Dealing With Self-Harm

10 Ways To Improve Your Body Image And Feel Better About Your Body

Girls Are Strong (And Boys Are, Too). 17 Ways To Be Strong

Want to write a book? Try Holly Lisle's How To Write A Novel course. I recommend all her courses; I've taken several and found them helpful.

Writing Technique Books I Recommend

Writing Technique Books & Online Courses I recommend, including those by Holly Lisle

Free writing course by Holly Lisle:Write Flash Fiction that Doesn't SUCK

Love my books?
Join my Street Team!

You'll get my gratitude, hear book news first, get swag, enter to win private contests, and more.

Cheryl Rainfield's Recommended YA Books on self-harm, sexual abuse, being queer, & more

Cheryl Rainfield: TV Interview DayTime Toronto

 Subscribe in a reader

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Cheryl Rainfield author FAQ

Cheryl Rainfield interview on Fox25

Self-Harm Is NOT Trendy

Cheryl Rainfield at Blogged Children's Books Blog Directory

Search & Win

Add This Blog to the JacketFlap Blog Reader

Recent Posts

Find a Book

Gifts for Booklovers

Picture Book Reviews & Lists

Teen & Children's Book Blogs

Teen Book Reviews & Lists


February 2011
« Jan   Mar »