Was Amazon homophobic? Or was it “simply” a technological error?

You may have read about the recent snafu with Amazon.com–where thousands of lesbian and gay books lost their sales rankings, which made them hard to find via a search. This included picture book Heather Has Two Mommies, and YA book The Filly.

Many writers and concerned readers wrote in to Amazon, and got elusive replies, or replies that stated that they were excluding “adult material” from their lists. Lesbian/gay books are not “adult material”–they are necessary literature! And if they were indeed doing that, it’s a form of censorship.

Later, after Amazon realized that scope of the problem, they said that it was a “glitch in its sales ranking feature” and that there is “no new adult policy”.

Twitter had lively, frequent discussions about this, especially with the tag #amazonfail. Some people thought that Amazon was deliberately removing the books, being homophobic, and creating censorship, while some people thought that it was indeed a technological error, and that cataloging is subjective.

I’m grateful that many people rose up to complain to Amazon, since otherwise this “glitch” may have just continued, or stayed the same, with lesbian/gay books being hard to find through searching. Instead, after so many people rose up to protest, Amazon took action, corrected the problem, and apologized: “an embarrassing and ham-fisted cataloging error” that pertained to 57,310 listings.

I am very glad that Amazon has corrected the issue–and so glad that people protested, which caused Amazon to respond. I still don’t know what the real story is, or what to believe. I know that technological errors can happen, though I think that Amazon’s initial response should have been better. Whatever the cause, I’m just glad that it’s over, and that those lesbian/gay books are now easy to find once again on Amazon.

What do you think? Was it censorship or a technological glitch?

About Cheryl Rainfield

I write the books I needed and couldn't find as a teen. I write teen fiction--paranormal fantasy and gritty realistic fiction. I'm the author of SCARS (WestSide Books, 2010) #1 ALA QuickPicks, and Governor General Literary Award Finalist, HUNTED (WestSide Books, Oct 2011), STAINED (Harcourt, 2013), The Last Dragon (HIP Books, Sept 2009), and Walking Both Sides (HIP Books, 2011). I also enjoy drawing, surfing the web, connecting with people I like, doing crafts, and being with my dog.
This entry was posted in Amazon.com, censorship, censorship in children's books and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Was Amazon homophobic? Or was it “simply” a technological error?

  1. Suzanne says:

    I know this is a bit delayed, but thanks so much for linking to my post on this issue! It’s wonderful that so many bloggers came out in full force and posted about this!

  2. Cheryl says:

    Suzanne, thanks is welcome at any time. 🙂 And I was glad to link to your post. Thank you for writing about it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.